Qualitative vs. quantitative data: which do you need?

George Denison

|

12

January 2023

Qualitative vs. quantitative data: which do you need?

George Denison

|

12

January 2023

There are two key types of data – qualitative and quantitative. But which do you need to use for your research?

The choice between qualitative vs. quantitative data depends on the topic and format of your study. You’ll also need to think about the kind of data you’d like to gather.

In this post, we’ll look at the difference between these two data types, and the pros and cons of each. We’ll also explain how to choose the right option for your research.

What is qualitative data?

Qualitative data is non-numerical. For example, it could be:

  • Long-form interviews
  • Diary entries
  • Media content
  • Focus group discussions

This data tends to be more open-ended. It’s a good option for exploratory research, as you can use it to identify connections between data.

Want to learn more about how your participants think and feel? Qualitative data is the best choice. You can also use it to analyze your topic in wider social contexts.

How to capture qualitative data

There are many different ways to get qualitative data. These include:

  • Semi-structured interviews
  • Group sessions
  • Diaries
  • Case study research

You can also gather it by analyzing other forms of non-numerical data, like photographs and videos.

Benefits of qualitative data

  • It gives you nuanced detail where numbers can’t. You get insight into the perspectives of your participants.
  • It’s a strong choice for exploratory research. That’s because it allows you to uncover potential connections between data. But it’s not generally used to prove causation.

Disadvantages of qualitative data

  • Qualitative data is more subjective. It focuses on broader personal experiences instead of hard stats. This makes it hard to determine external validity.
  • With qualitative data, the researcher plays a more integral role to the research. This means you can't replicate qualitative studies to support (or refute) their validity. Also, you can’t generalize them outside of the study itself.
  • This form of data takes more time to gather. It also includes fewer participants. The larger number of participants in quantitative studies is better for generalizing the findings.
  • Qualitative data is more open to researcher bias.

What is quantitative data?

Quantitative data is numerical data. You can typically collect it on a much larger scale than qualitative data. This means it can reflect a more diverse range of perspectives, making it ideal for confirmatory research and hypothesis testing.

Do you want to explore a specific hypothesis through your research? If so, then quantitative data is the best option.  

How to capture quantitative data

You can gather quantitative data through experiments, surveys, and other tests. These give you numerical or other categorical data that you can analyze using statistics.

Quantitative data limits the types of responses that participants can provide. For example, you might use a Likert scale, where the participant submits how strongly they feel about a statement – from “strongly agree” to “strongly disagree”. With this scale alone, they can only give limited information. This restricts the depth of their responses.

Benefits of quantitative data

  • This data is usually made up of hard numbers, which makes it much less subjective. So, you can replicate the results of studies using quantitative data.
  • You can test hypotheses with quantitative data.
  • Quantitative data is typically faster to analyze than qualitative data, because it can be coded and manipulated in a wide range of software.

Disadvantages of quantitative data

  • Quantitative data limits the types of responses participants can give. It also restricts their depth, removing the context of the responses. This means participants can’t explain their reasoning or provide further details.
  • For quantitative data to be accurate and generalizable, you need a large sample size.

Which option is right for my study?

When it comes down to qualitative vs. quantitative data, your research question will determine which is suited to your study.

Qualitative data is a great choice for developing a broader understanding of a topic. You can use it to gain insight from real-life experiences. Through this, you'll uncover new paths of inquiry for future research. For example, you could conduct interviews to find out about a person’s experience with a new piece of software. Without the constraints of a questionnaire, the participant can tell you about their experiences in detail. This way, you can learn about the context behind their answers.

But if there’s already extensive research on the topic, quantitative data is the best option. You can use it to test hypotheses. Quantitative studies are also generalizable - and you can replicate them. For example, if the qualitative data suggested that participants had negative experiences with the software, you could use a questionnaire to test this. This would allow you to confirm the hypothesis with a much larger group of people.

These two types of data can inform each other when used over multiple studies – much like with exploratory and confirmatory research. With qualitative data, you can’t test a hypothesis. But you can uncover potential hypotheses for future studies. You can then test these with quantitative data in a confirmatory study.

Gain unique insights with high-quality data

Whether you want to test a hypothesis or discover new insights, data is the beating heart of research. Qualitative and quantitative data need to be high-quality. Without this, researchers run the risk of replicating unconscious biases. They could even reduce the validity of their own studies.  

Prolific offers a gold standard for online research. That’s thanks to our 130,000+ vetted participants who are ready to take part in your online surveys. Tailoring your participants has never been easier. You’ll also have 200+ pre-screening filters at your fingertips.

Reach out to trusted research participants today. Get started with Prolific now.

Leave your details below and someone will get back to you